The selection of former Iowa Gov. Tom Vilsack as U.S. Secretary of Agriculture was more political pay back to the Hawkeye State than smart policy, according to an editorial by the Fort Dodge Messenger.
The Messenger, which endorsed John McCain, calls the move a “thank you” to Iowa for helping get Barack Obama elected president and calls into question Vilsack’s skills for the job.
It’s probably good news that an Iowan has been selected to fill this important post. Obviously the decisions made at the USDA have an enormous impact on the Hawkeye State’s economy. Clearly, any former Iowa governor would have at least some familiarity with farm life. It doesn’t seem obvious from Vilsack’s career, however, that his knowledge of agriculture goes much beyond the minimum one would expect from any farm state politician. Being a Des Moines lawyer isn’t the ideal preparation for the country’s most important agriculture post.
It is true that Vilsack as governor worked hard to promote Iowa products including the rapidly growing renewable fuels industries. The homework behind those efforts should be a useful starting point for leading the USDA. Certainly, having Vilsack at the USDA will make it easier for Iowans to get a friendly hearing at the department. It’s not so certain, however, that Vilsack brings to this new assignment the broad-ranging knowledge of agriculture that would be desirable for one occupying this crucial post.
(h/t Doug Burns at Iowa Political Alert)