Top Stories

Open letter to readers: Today and tomorrow

By Lynda Waddington | 11.17.11

Wednesday was a difficult day for The American Independent News Network, which is the larger entity that operates The Iowa Independent. Our chief executive and founder announced two of our sister sites would close and their content would be moved to The American Independent.

ACS lockout continues; plan emerges to repeal sugar protections

By Virginia Chamlee | 11.15.11

A recently introduced bill could have far-reaching impact on the U.S. sugar industry, including American Crystal Sugar, a farmer-owned cooperative that locked out 1,300 Midwest workers on Aug. 1.

Cain campaign: Farmers know more about regulations than EPA

By Andrew Duffelmeyer | 11.15.11

The chairman for Herman Cain’s Iowa effort says the campaign “relied more on the word of farmers than Washington regulators” in deciding to run an ad containing claims the Environmental Protection Agency says are false.

Mathis wins, Democrats maintain Senate control

Liz Mathis
By Lynda Waddington | 11.08.11

The Iowa Senate will remain under the control of a slim 26-25 Democratic majority when it reconvenes in January 2012.

Press Release

PR: Nation should work to address veterans’ challenges

By Press Release Reprints | 11.11.11

BRUCE BRALEY RELEASE — As US involvement in Iraq and Afghanistan ends, it’s more important than ever that our nation works to address the challenges faced by the men and women who fought there.

PR: Honoring veterans, help in hiring

By Press Release Reprints | 11.11.11

CHUCK GRASSLEY RELEASE — A difficult job market is challenging the soldiers, sailors and airmen who have protected America’s interests by serving in the Armed Forces.

PR: In honor of America’s veterans

By Press Release Reprints | 11.11.11

TOM LATHAM RELEASE — No one has done more to secure the freedom enjoyed by every single American than our veterans and those currently serving in the armed services.

PR: Honoring and supporting our nation’s veterans

By Press Release Reprints | 11.11.11

DAVE LOEBSACK RELEASE — Veterans Day is an opportunity to reflect on the service of generations of veterans and to honor the sacrifices they and their families have made so that we may live in peace and freedom here at home.

Beef processor wants Iowa State to keep ammonia research documents hush-hush

By Lynda Waddington | 02.02.10 | 2:42 pm

A public records request to Iowa State University has met with stiff resistance from Beef Products Inc. (BPI), a company with strong Iowa ties that pioneered ammonia-based beef processing recently featured in a national expose on pathogens in school lunches. At the heart of the disagreement is Iowa’s oft-criticized 1967 public records law.

Just before a recent New York Times report on the use of ammonia in beef processing published, a Seattle-based food safety law firm formally requested Iowa State provide all public records related to research completed by a professor on the safety of the process. Although university officials gathered 1,650 documents and received more than $2,000 from the firm to pay for the copies, the records were never sent to the Marler Clark law firm. Beef Products Inc. filed an injunction in Iowa District Court for Story County, asserting that release of the documents could disclose trade secrets.

According to Michael Moss, author of The Times’ report, the U.S. Department of Agriculture’s Food Safety and Inspection Service relied on research generated by the Iowa State professor, showing that the process was an effective killer of pathogens such as E. coli.

“Frankly, I thought the public should know what BPI, the USDA/FSIS and the beef industry were relying on to serve us the ammonia ‘fatty trimmings the industry once relegated to pet food and cooking oil,’” wrote attorney Bill Marler on the company’s blog while referring to the Times’ report. “I would have assumed BPI, the USDA/FSIS and the beef industry would feel the same way? Well, BPI did not.”

BPI, which is being represented by the Shuttleworth & Ingersoll law firm in Cedar Rapids, is arguing that the services of James S. Dickson, an Iowa State professor, were purchased directly from Dickson as a private contractor and not as a representative of the university, and that Dickson remains under a non-disclosure agreement. The company further argues that since Dickson worked as an independent contractor of the company, all of the documents related to his research are the property of BPI and not of Iowa State.

The disclosure of said information would disclose and divulge confidential trade secrets of BPI and would cause irreparable injury to BPI for which BPI has not adequate remedy at law. Such disclosure is prohibited by Chapter 22, Code of Iowa.

Even if the court determines that the information is not the property of BPI, the injunction states, it must still prohibit disclosure of such confidential records to third parties by virtue of the same statute, which is the state’s public records law. The fourth subsection of the statute, named “exceptions,” refers to Chapter 550, which deals specifically with trade secrets, and quotes a 1980 opinion by the Iowa Attorney General that “if an agency has reasonable grounds for concluding that an item is a trade secret, it need not make the item available for inspection and copying.”  The Code states overall that any public records deemed confidential “shall be kept confidential unless otherwise ordered by a court, the lawful custodian, or another person duly authorized to release information.”

In a letter to Iowa State University, Marler questions whether or not Dickson’s research and subsequent documentation is confidential under Iowa law.

“Just because BPI filed a petition claiming that some records we seek contain trade secrets, or relate to work that Dr. Dickson did as an ‘independent contractor,’ that does not mean there is a reasonable basis for refusing to disclose the already-gathered documents,” he wrote. “We are also troubled by the fact of Dr. Dickson having published an article in the Journal of Food Protection that extensively discusses allegedly ‘confidential’ research on behalf of BPI, that the research was also supported by Hatch Act and State of Iowa funds, and that his consulting work for BPI would have needed approval by the University to avoid conflicts of interest.”

Marler also notes that he does not believe it is his firm’s place to intervene in the action against ISU since his firm does not know the content of the information in question.

“Indeed, if the university allows a default judgment to be entered, and an injunction to issue, when it knows that BPI is not otherwise entitled to such relief, the the University’s failure to act could be construed as causing the denial of rights under the public records law,” he said.

The firm has amended its prior public records request to include “all records related to Dickson’s consulting work for BPI; how such work was approved and monitored; disclosure of any conflicts of interest; whether federal, USDA, or Iowa state funds were used to support the work; other grants sponsored or funded by BPI at the University; research notes, data, article-drafts, related papers, and other documents that relate to Dr. Dickson’s Research Note published in the 2003 Journal of Food Protection, vol. 66, pages 847-877.”

BPI links to a report from Iowa State University on its Web site; however, that report, labeled as a “brief statement of the use of ammonium compounds in food processing,” was written by Sam Beattie and not Dickson.

Follow Lynda Waddington on Twitter


  • davidbaer

    Cash Making Opportunities – The Beginning The working life is already tough enough, but the worries of being out of work was even tougher. The unsecured working environment have prompted me to search the internet for an alternative source of extra income so that I could learn how to Make Money Work for me and be Financially Independent. I listed down a number of Free Internet Business Opportunity Ideas while researching ways how people earn money online while working-from-home…….

  • public records

    Here are the top 5 related documents. pagerank. Iowa State; ENG 528 (Fall, 2009) ….. ammonia ammoniac ammonias ammoniate ammonic ammonite ammonites ammonium ….. beebread beech beechen beechnut beef beefcake beefeater beefed beefier

Switch to our mobile site